Thursday, May 30, 2013

Outweighing the Costs



An earlier story this week looked at the cost of transporting the Saints to the Salt Lake Valley. Cheapest was best in most cases, but not in all. For instance, it was cheaper to have the immigrating Saints sail to New Orleans, transfer to riverboats and then paddle their way north to Nauvoo. However, there are times when cheapest isn’t always best and this route of travel came to a halt by Church leaders.  The Church chose the more expensive route of gathering the Saints by sailing the immigrants to the ports of New York, Boston, or Philadelphia, and then using the railroads to transport to the staging camps at the railhead in Iowa City.
Why did Brigham Young use the more expensive route?

     a.      More and more people were paying tithing, which allowed for the comfort of travel by train
     b.      The number of deaths from cholera coming up the Mississippi
     c.       The amount of persecutions endured on the riverboats
     d.      From months of lack of exercise on sailing vessels and river boats took away much of the leg strength the Saints desperately needed to cross the plains
Yesterday’s answer:

     a.      A trade gone bad involving flour and fish

In 1853, open warfare commenced [natives and Saints], again in Utah Valley, when an argument over a simple trade of fish for flour lit the match on what has been called the Walker War. Brigham Young immediately dispatched orders that “no retaliation be made and no offense offered but for all to act entirely on the defense until further orders”—to no avail. Discipline cracked and a spate of brutal killings occurred as each side retaliated against the other. Apparently exasperated by such indiscipline and carnage, in October Brigham Young pleaded: “Brethren we must have peace. We must cease our hostilities and seek by every possible means to reach the Indians with a peaceful message. In the spring of 1854, after offering full amnesty, Governor Young met with Chief Walkara in the chief’s tent, blessed a sick child, purchased a slave as a further gesture, and the war was over.


Plewe, Brandon S., et. at., Mapping Mormonism (Provo, Utah: Brigham Young University Press, 2012) 100.

No comments:

Post a Comment